WELCOME TO MUSTANG HARRY’S

Reserved here for lunch on 3/16/19 with a group of 8. Far less crowded than a lot of places since it was St. Patrick's Day weekend, so that was a plus! Bar was huge, restaurant clean, food was really good..LOVED  the calamari! Staff were friendly and efficient. Will definitely be a repeat customer when in the city.

Owner Niall Conroe really knows how to treat his customers. We walked in inquiring about Happy Hour. The hostess said it was over at 6. So we were leaving, Niall comes behind us and offers to extend the Happy Hour to us and gives us VIP treatment. Let's just say, our 1 drink turned into 4. His service and hospitality made our visit all worth while! We will definitely be back and bring some more friends.

So we came here because it was close to Madison square garden and we were going to a show ... I made reservations because I knew that places around events and at happy hr time can get packed and I was right.

Unfortunately the traffic was horrible that day - and even tho I called that was was running a lil late- by the time I parked in the deck across the street and came in- I arrived 20 mins after my reservation. Also the table they were going to give us was going to be upstairs - unfortunately my sister who was ubering from another location - broke her foot and had one of those scooters so it was be impossible to get her to the upstairs floor. I get it- the front desk was annoyed with me but these were the circumstances and it was also my sister's bday that I wrote on the reservation. Anyway they didn't have any 3 seats downstairs even though I saw plenty of seating lol. Anyway I opted to take the two seater and I would stand but when our sweet waitress came over - I told her the situation - she talked to her boss Nile and he gave us a better table with three seats like no problem!!!!

Awesome . We were situated by the time by sister arrived. I don't remember the other waitress's name but I was very thankful.  Our new waitress Rachael was also a gem- attentive and friendly.

I had the Harry's Martini twice cuz it was super yummy. But step pops had a beer and sister had wine

They ordered the burgers and I got the fried chicken sandwich. They said they liked their meal. The chicken sandwich and fries were ok but I ate it because I was so hungry since it was the only thing I ate that day.

Out waitress Rachael was able to figure out my sly cryptic non verbal movements to get a Birthday dessert for my sister in which her and her coworkers helped sing happy birthday for my sister . It was a success! My sister had a string of bad luck including breaking her ankle 2 days before birthday and her long awaited tickets to see John Mayer at Garden .

So this is my breakdown
Food 3/4
Drink 4

Service 5 by Nile, Rachael and the other waitress who helped us get a better table!!! Thank you so much

Wonderful experience. It was a great atmosphere with friendly service. The owner even took his time to come and check on us. Order the calamari it is out of this world.

The food and atmosphere was awesome. We were visiting from Baltimore and wanted to catch the Ravens game after watching a show on broadway. We had a group of six and got there midway into third quarter and the wait was only a few minutes. The place was packed.. food was excellent! We loved the lamb lollipops, calamari, Brussels sprouts, fish tacos, beef lettuce wraps and fish tacos. Niall the owner was very friendly and so was our waitress... we highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for great food and a fun atmosphere!

Service was good, as we had a large party.  The temperature , it was extremely hot, and they did turn on the air for us.  Initially when I arrived, I sat at the bar, and the bar tender needs to be more attentive to his customers.  I was trying to flag him down for a beer.  Someone else came in, and sat to my left and got served right away.
The food, nothing g to write home about - the appetizers, sliders, calamari and chicken wings, standard.  I ordered the Shepherds Pie, and it was bland, lacked seasoning--wouldn't order again.  Again, the server for our table was very good. The bartender and food, not so much.

Came here after a rangers game. Place was busy but we got seated pretty quick. The Food came quick and was amazing!!!!
Our waitress and the staff was super friendly. I highly recommend this place. I Will definitely be back!

i can't claim that we sampled a lot of food here or spent a lot of time, but i enjoyed the ambiance, the service was impeccable, and the "bar food"/appetizers that we had were flavorful and satisfying.

my dinner companion raved about the disco fries, which i had never had, but i found them a little short on the meat since i was on a hunt for protein.  the brussel sprouts, which we ordered after seeing another review here, were delicious, although the bacon was mushy, and i hate mushy bacon.  i'm not sure what the solution would be to keeping the bacon crispy, but i would recommend that the chef figure something out.  both of those dishes were a little greasy as well -- especially the brussel sprouts -- but i guess that's bar food for you.

the chicken-nuggety things really hit the spot for me.  i don't know if they use a house hot sauce but it was delicious, and the nuggets were meaty and crispy and not greasy, as some can be.

it was a great place to stop for something quick and gratifying to the palate, as you bop around the penn station area in your manhattan wanderings!

The beer selection is meh.  While I like hip-hop sometimes.  Hearing it so loud I couldn't have a conversation with my company was annoying.  It didn't seem to match the mood/vibe of the bar.  The bar tender must really like it or something.

Worst service! Sat for 10 mins with not even a hello. Had to ask for a server twice. Go elsewhere and save yourself the trouble of this place.

Have been here before and the service was slow. This time was so bad I left.

Shout out to Sharon, great service. Went in for beers after work, good vibe, good beers, really good nachos. Definitely will be back

What a fantastic bar the owners Niall & Ian along with their brilliant staff make you more then welcome. We were staying in New York for 4 days on transit to Ireland when we came across this bar it serves the best of food with a wide range of offers some great daily specials and a very nice breakfast to set you on the way. Thank you for the warm welcome and I would tell anyone passing by to drop in and feel relaxed enjoying your food and drink.

My family has a reservation tonight for 6:30. They called to confirm and we did. We were a party of 10 coming from upstate and had delays due to the train and taxi ride over. When we got there at 6:15, we were told our table was given away. There was no offer to give us another table, we even offered to be split up.
Front desk staff was rude and condescending.

Made reservations for this restaurant. We had to wait an additional 45 mins. The short guy at the front desk was really rude and didn't care that we were pushed back. We ended up leaving and going somewhere else where they sat our party and we made it to our show ontime.

Let's talk about Mustang Harry's! This is a bar in Chelsea that's close to MSG and Penn Station. Despite there not being a game or big event, there was a decent crowd on a regular Saturday afternoon. The place is dark, but lively.

My mom and I were seated at a high top and we ordered drinks and shareables. We ordered the roasted cauliflower salad along with the loaded chicken nachos to get a delicate balance of healthy and unhealthy. Portions were decently sized without being Cheesecake Factory-esque.

The roasted cauliflower salad was fresh and tasted well made, without being overly dressed or adorned. All the flavors and greens complimented each other well and made it feel like you weren't eating pure pub food. The nachos were also awesome! Chicken was a little on the dry/plain side, but this was made up for the fact that these nachos were covered in cheese, black beans, salsa, sour cream and jalapeño, so all the accompanying accoutrements brought the whole dish together.

Service was, admittedly, a little slow. It took a little time for us to be seated, get food and drinks, and get our check. I have a pretty vivid memory of us clearing our check before a server came and cleared our empty plates. Maybe a slow day?

Otherwise, this is a decent find close to MSG, so be sure to stop before games, concerts, or even happy hour.

Classy bar with great food and service We spent a week in NYC and stayed in a hotel around the corner. After trying several other bars, we found this gem. The bar has a nice feel and the service was warm and friendly.

The slow cooked rib is amazing - so tender and delicious. We also enjoyed the Caesar salad and the wings.

We went back for drinks and food several times over the week.

Thanks Kevin, Liam, Niall and Ian for such friendly and welcoming service.

Came to NYC for the holidays and the best part was visiting Mustang Harry's to watch the Ravens game. Food was amazing as well as the experience. Service was amazing! Had a chance to meet the owner Niall who really made this place an incredible experience for us. Definitely recommend the Lamb Lollipops, calamari, and lettuce wraps. Thanks again Niall for an amazing time!

Great bar and bartenders. Ambience is great!  Not to crowded in a Tuesday eve. Bet it gets packed later in the week!!

This restaurant is our favorite restaurant near Penn Station and  Madison Garden.  Everything here is top notch. Especially the service. All the waitservice is courteous and knowledgeable about the menu. The ambience is casual and the food is outstanding. The selection is gourmet with choices for bar food and entrees. There are also daily specials. I love the menu because the chef made sure to include a vegan dish with farro  grain and vegetables which I really like. There  are other choices which are the usual vegetarian too like salads etc.   In addition the menu includes more standard fare like steak and seafood. Besides this the bartenders are experts at making delish cocktails and there is a full choice of alcholic drinks too, like beers and wines. This restaurant would be great for a date or to go to before an event at the Garden. Hope you go there soon.

Went there yesterday with a group of 6 people from Italy had great time nice service by a young server. Great nachos, sliders, calamari.all my guest love the place . Nice portions .